Democracy Dialogue: Global Conversations Inspired by Egypt’s January 25 Revolution

[Photo by Mosa`ab Elshami] [Photo by Mosa`ab Elshami]

Democracy Dialogue: Global Conversations Inspired by Egypt’s January 25 Revolution

By : Jadaliyya Reports

Democracy Dialogue (DD) is a multimedia project inspired by the Egyptian revolution of January 25, 2011. Developed with a team from the Global Studies in Education (GSE) program at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, the website houses original videos and transcripts in Arabic, Urdu, Chinese, English and Korean, all licensed under the Creative Commons and available for free download.

Though the project takes Egypt’s January 25 uprising as a starting point, it aims to probe pressing global questions about the history of freedom movements, citizenship, security, equality, democracy, popular uprisings and alternative politics.

The first installment of videos is from a historic conversation that took place during the turbulent post-revolution period in Egypt in 2012 between Mohamed ElBaradei, Nobel Peace Prize laureate and former head of the Dostour Party, and Rajmohan Gandhi, grandson and biographer of Mahatma Gandhi, as well as a peace activist, former parliamentarian and retired University of Illinois professor. The pairing of these two figures speaks to the humanistic bent of this project.

[Democracy Dialogue Trailer]

Linda Herrera answered the following questions about the project:

Why did you want to launch Democracy Dialogue on the five-year anniversary of the Egyptian revolution?

The five-year anniversary of the January 25 revolution calls for commemoration and, yes, celebration. Many analysts, when referring to the Egyptian and other Arab uprisings, cavalierly invoke the tired cliché about how the “Arab Spring has turned into the Arab Winter.” While we cannot deny that much of the political, economic and social reality in the region is currently bleak—if not positively dire in countries such as Syria, Libya, Yemen and Iraq — it is not the end of the story.

The Arab uprisings, a mere five years young, are still in their infancy. However demoralizing the current situation may be, the uprisings constituted an “event,” to use the terminology of Alain Badiou in Ethics—a rupture with the past that “compels us to decide a new way of being.” Along these lines, Democracy Dialogue is intended to engage thinkers, activists, public figures, artists—young and old alike—about the meaning and practice of democracy in an age of uprisings, political turmoil, mass migrations and unimaginable opportunities for communication, spreading ideas and forging alternatives.

How did the encounter between Mohamed ElBaradei and Rajmohan Gandhi come into being?

The remarkable encounter between ElBaradei and Gandhi, like so many of the exceptional “events” in life, came about through the combination of serendipity and the work and support of many people.

The seeds of this project began on the occasion of the one-year anniversary of the January 25 revolution. The Egyptian Student Association invited me to speak on a panel about youth politics. One of my fellow panelists, an Egyptian researcher from the Institute for Genome Biology, Magdy al-Abady, was interested in the influence of Gandhi in Egypt. I told him that Gandhi’s grandson Rajmohan, an important historian and peace activist, was a professor on our campus. Shortly thereafter, we met with Professor Gandhi and his wife Usha. As we talked about the rising tensions and social cleavages in Egypt, Gandhi drew insightful parallels with India’s independence movement. We understood that this conversation would be of great value and interest in Egypt. On the spot, without knowing how to actualize it, I proposed to bring the Gandhis on a kind of solidarity trip to Egypt. We immediately started envisioning a meeting with youth groups and with Mohamed ElBaradei, the unifying voice of the liberal opposition at that time. Yes, we were dreaming big, but that was a time for dreaming.

Since I had no clue whatsoever how to contact ElBaradei directly, I turned to Abdel Rahman Mansour, a youth activist and friend who had worked on ElBaradei’s Facebook page. He reached out to ElBaradei’s brother, Ali, and explained our proposition to hold a two-day dialogue with ElBaradei and Gandhi. At that moment, Ali was reading Rajmohan’s magisterial biography about his grandfather, Gandhi: The Man, His People, and the Empire. He liked our idea and put me in touch with ElBaradei’s assistant. In the meantime, I started knocking on doors at the university to raise funds to support our small delegation to travel to Egypt and cover the costs of filming the dialogue (thanks goes to International Programs and Studies, Office of Public Engagement and the College of Education).

Ten months later, in November 2012 we were in Egypt in a hotel meeting room converted into a makeshift recording studio for a two-day, six-hour dialogue between ElBaradei and Gandhi. ElBaradei graciously agreed to a follow-up interview with me on 1 June 2013, as did Aida ElBaradei. Rajmohan and Usha Gandhi have lent much support to the project, as well as the team of students from Global Studies in Education who are working on translations and various aspects of the project. I also need to give recognition to the phenomenal Egyptian photographer  Mosa`ab Elshamy, who has so generously given us permission to use his stunning photographs throughout the videos and website.

How is working with video different or similar to working with text? 

I am accustomed to editing written work, to dealing with large reams of research data and pulling out a coherent story. I applied the conventional skills of editing text to the editing of the videos. It was humbling to open my first Premiere Pro project and not know how to begin. I am eternally grateful to all those wonderful video enthusiasts and geeks who have made YouTube a global school and resource. I have spent countless hours watching their tutorials and how-to videos. I have also turned to my media and video-savvy daughters, Shiva and Tara, who have always given me good advice. I am still very much an amateur video creator, and can only hope viewers will be forgiving of my limitations and technical shortcomings. I am working on them.

As an educator and academic, I am convinced of the need to continue working with video material in addition to written texts. Video is surpassing every other media as the premiere means of communication, documentation and creative expression of all sorts. On YouTube alone, 6 billion hours of video are watched per month, and each day 1 billion videos are watched via mobile phone! Video is not the way of the future — it is an indispensable mode of learning and disseminating research and ideas in the present.

Do you have other plans for this set of interview material, and for Democracy Dialogue?

I personally continue to be inspired by the interview material over three years on. So far, it has spawned five Democracy Dialogue video vignettes with five more on the way, totaling about 90 minutes. I will continue mining the material for more transcripts, including one with Aida ElBaradei. These are in addition to a short, half-hour documentary I co-produced and co-directed in 2013 with the Alexandria-based production house Fig Leaf Studio called The Long March. However, as the political situation rapidly deteriorated in Egypt, the Egyptian colleagues requested to put the release of that short film on indefinite hold, and I concurred.

Now, with the Democracy Dialogue videos out as part of the Creative Commons, I imagine they will take a life of their own. I am open to new forms of creative collaboration. I am starting to plan for a forthcoming series of Democracy Dialogues around the issues of refugees, the politics of citizenship and education. 

[This report is published in collaboration with Mada Masr]  


[Video segment on Citizenship and Minorities with Arabic subtitles]

 

[Video segment on Building Political Structures]

[The Democracy Dialogue videos and transcripts are copyrighted to Linda Herrera of the University of Illinois and under the Creative Commons license, Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike CC BY-NC-SA.]

  • ALSO BY THIS AUTHOR

    • Jadaliyya Co-Editor Noura Erakat Discusses Mahmoud Khalil Arrest and Trump's Abuses on Democracy Now!

      Jadaliyya Co-Editor Noura Erakat Discusses Mahmoud Khalil Arrest and Trump's Abuses on Democracy Now!

      Jadaliyya co-editor Noura Erakat joined Democracy Now! to discuss the unjust arrest and detainment of Columbia graduate and Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil, as well as the bipartisan complicity in perpetuating anti-Palestinian rhetoric responsible for the suppression of free speech among activists historically. In this interview, Erakat emphasizes on the importance of continuing to resist the tyranny of American imperialism and Zionism in the wake of neocolonial racism. 

    • REGISTER NOW: The Critical Amazigh Studies Summer Institute (30 June - 11 July)

      REGISTER NOW: The Critical Amazigh Studies Summer Institute (30 June - 11 July)

      Over the past two decades, Amazigh Studies has gained momentum, fostering new academic and cultural initiatives in both North Africa and the Anglophone world. This Critical Amazigh Studies Summer Institute (CASSI) aims to remedy the shortcomings of the current situation of Amazigh studies in Anglophone academia by offering seminars, lectures, workshops, and language learning opportunities, equipping participants with the crucial tools they need to engage critically with Amazigh cultural production, historiography, and critical scholarship. 

    • Jadaliyya Co-Editor Mouin Rabbani Discusses US Direct Negotiations with Hamas on MSNBC (10 March)

      Jadaliyya Co-Editor Mouin Rabbani Discusses US Direct Negotiations with Hamas on MSNBC (10 March)

      In this interview with Ayman Mohieddin for MSNBC, Jadaliyya Co-Editor Mouin Rabbani discusses the context, opportunities, and pitfalls of Washington engaging in unprecedented direct negotiations with Hamas. The opportunities presented by Washington’s recent outreach to Tehran is also considered.

May Ziada: A Profile from the Archives

[”A Profile from the Archives“  is a series published by Jadaliyya in both Arabic and English in cooperation with the Lebanese newspaper, Assafir. These profiles will feature iconic figures who left indelible marks in the politics and culture of the Middle East and North Africa. This profile was originally published in Arabic  and was translated by Mazen Hakeem.]

Name: May

Last Name: Ziada

Father’s Name: Elias

Mother’s Name: Nizha Muammar

Place of Birth: Nazareth, Palestine

Date of Birth: 1886

Date of Death: 1941

Nationality: Lebanese

Category: Writer

Profession: Author

 

 \"\"

May Ziada
 

  • A Lebanese national.
  • Birth name: Mary, she later reduced it to “May,” and used this name to sign her Arabic articles. She also signed her French poems using the pen name Isis Copia. She also wrote using the pen name Aida. Gibran Khalil Gibran gave her the name Mariam.
  • Born on 11 February 1886 in Nazareth, Palestine.
  • Her father, Elias Zakhour Ziada, was from the village of Shahtool, Kisrwan in Lebanon. He travelled to Palestine and worked as a teacher in one of the schools.
  • Her mother, Nizha Khalil Muammar, originally from Horan, Syria, was Palestinian.
  • Raised as an only-child after the death of her brother while still a young child.
  • Went to the Nuns of Joseph School in Nazareth when she was six, and finished at thirteen. She then went to Lebanon where she went to Nuns of the Visitation School in Aintoora, Kisrwan, to finish her secondary education.
  • Finished her learning in Aintoora in 1904 and then went back to Nazareth.
  • She loved music and learned to play the piano.
  • In 1907, she moved with her parents to Cairo where she started giving private tutoring lessons to the children of Idris Beik Ragheb, a rich Egyptian. She continued her study of German, Spanish, and Italian in addition to French and English.
  • In 1909, Idris Beik Ragheb donated Al-Mahrooseh newspaper and its print press to her. Doors opened up to her as her father became the Editor in Chief and she started publishing her first articles.
  • In 1910, she went to Lebanon and spent her vacation in the town of Dhoor Al-Shwair. During this time, she met Amin Al-Rihani and visited his village, Al-Freekeh.
  • In 1910, the connection between her and Gibran Khalil started. They started exchanging letters but they did not meet. This correspondence lasted for twenty years.
  • Her literary fame began in Egypt, in 1913 to be precise, during a festivity in honor of Khalil Matar. The festivity was held by Saleem Sarkees. On that day, she was entrusted with delivering a speech in Gibran’s name which was followed by a speech of her own. She succeeded in both. Prince Muhammad Ali stood up and gave her a handshake and congratulated her.
  • Established her own weekly seminar in her house in Cairo, which went on for twenty years. Some of the people who attended this seminar include: Wali Al-Deen Yakan, Taha Hussein, Khalil Matar, Shibli Al-Shumail, Yakoub Sarrouf, Antoun Al-Jamil, Ahmad Loutfi Al-Sayyed, Abbas Mahmud Al-Akkad, Mustafa Sadik Al-Rifai, and Ahmed Shawki.
  • Went to the Egyptian University in 1914 where she studied Arabic literature and philosophy and Islamic history. She graduated in 1917.
  • Met Mrs. Huda Sha’rawi in college. She collaborated with her on liberating Arab women from ignorance, tyranny, and slavery.
  • Elected as a corresponding member to the literary association Pen Bond, al-rabitah al-qalamiah, in New York in 1920. Mikha`il Na`ima was the one who nominated her.
  • In 1932, she retired from her literary life after the death of her parents in 1929 and the death of Gibran Khalil Gibran in 1931.
  • Lived her life as a single woman.
  • Travelled to France and England in 1932 and then to Italy where she went to the University of Perugia to study the influence of the Italian language. In Italy, however, she started feeling fatigue and exhaustion soon thereafter she returned to Cairo. Symptoms of hysteria intensified up to the point where she attempted to commit suicide.
  • In 1936, she went to Beirut and was admitted to the Al-A’sfoorieh mental health facility. Ten months later, she was discharged and transferred to Ribiz Hospital and then after that to a room in the American University.
  • In the summer of 1937, she stayed for two days in Al-Rihani’s house and then moved to a house right across from his in Al-Freekeh and spent three months there.
  • On 22 March 1938, she gave a lecture at the American University after an invitation from the Firm Bond Association, al-oo’rwah al-wothqa. Everyone was assured that her mental health was sound.
  • Came back to Cairo after that only to be shocked by a lawsuit seeking to place her property under guardianship which was filed against her by her cousin. She won the lawsuit but lost her health.
  • Died on 19 October 1941 in Al-Ma’adi Hospital in Cairo. She was buried in the cemetery of the Maronites, Misr Al-Qadimeh, Cairo, next to her parents.
  • A statue was built on commission to commemorate her; and a tribute celebration was held under the patronage of the Ministry of Culture and Higher Education in Beirut in 1999.
  • Published many articles and researches in the most famous Egyptian newspapers and magazines, e.g. Al-Moqattam, Al-Ahram, Al-Zohoor, Al-Mahrooseh, and Al-Hilal.


Some of her publications:

 

  • Flowers of a Dream, azaheer holm, (in French – 1911); published using the pen name Isis Copia.
  • The Return of the Wave, rojoo’ al-mwjah, (translated from French – 1912).
  • Smiles and Tears, ibtisamat wa domoo’, (translated from German – 1913).
  • The Researcher of the Desert, bahithet al-badiah, (1920).
  • The Purpose of Life, ghayet al-hayat, (1921).
  • The Tourists of a Girl, sawa’ih fatat, (1922).
  • Words and Signs, kalimat wa isharat, (1922).
  • Equality, al-mosawat, (1923).
  • Newspapers, al-saha’if, (1934).
  • Between the Ebb and Flood, bayna al-jazr wa al-mad, (1934).
  • Author’s Letter to the Life of Arabia, risalat al-adeeb ila hayat al-a’rabia, (1938).
  • Live in Danger, i`sh fi khatar, (1941).
  • The Letters, al-rasa’il, (1948).
  • It is said that May has several unpublished books, including: Nights of Al-A’sfoorieh, layali al-o’sfoorieh; From World Literature, mina al-adab al-a’lami; The Image on the Rock, al-khayal a’la al-sakhra; and Memories from College, thekriat mina al-jami’ah.